Local Maximum
  • Home
  • Blog
  • BP - Skill Drills
    • Why BP*?
    • How I Use BP - Skill Drills
    • Fractions
    • Decimals
    • Integers
    • More on the way
  • About
  • Number Patterns
    • Same/Different
    • Notice/Wonder

What's So Funny About Peace, Love and Multiplication? Part 1

2/14/2016

1 Comment

 
By the time the students get to my pre-algebra class, they’ve  learned "facts" about multiplication and division that lock them in, and actually make it harder to learn the next bits.  The misconceptions or limitations in their thinking show up when we begin to solve equations that involve fraction answers or operations.  I wonder if we shouldn’t start differently at the beginning.  From simplest to most subtle, these are three of the misconceptions that cause the most trouble:

  1. There are some numbers that don’t go into other numbers.
  2. Multiplication and division are opposites.
  3. Multiplication is the same forwards and backwards.

I will tackle each one in its own post.
1) There are some numbers that don't go into other numbers.  This shows up when we get to 5x = 13, and the students tell me “5 doesn’t go into 13.”  We use bar models before we use algebraic notation, so the problem looks like this:

Picture
And with the problem visually represented this way, the students can conclude for themselves that dividing by 5 will get them the value of one of the unknown units.  They will happily answer when the division comes out evenly, but when it doesn’t, some will report “I don’t know what to do.” (Have you noticed this? Sometimes, rather than say “I know I have divide by 5 but I don’t know how” the students’ brains seem to back out of what appears to be a dead-end, and deny that it ever existed in the first place.  … Makes me wonder about my own invisible dead-ends.)
 
I have learned to frontload work with division problems with fraction answers at the very start of the year so this doesn’t happen.  We use things like granola bars and sandwiches and we also use bar models to explore cutting things up.  The students need to see what it means to divide 13 into 5 equal shares, or, for 5x = 3/7, how to divide 3/7 into 5 equal shares.  

In a later post, I will talk about the problem with seeing 5 • 3 as the same as 3 • 5, but it comes up here.  There is another way to interpret 13 ÷ 5... or more accurately, 13 ÷ 5 can also represent this question: how many times does 5 go into 13?  Again, this is an easy question that becomes more challenging once fractions are involved.  The students need time to explore what it means for 5 to go into 13 two and three fifths times. 

And here is the rub:  one might ask why bother with all of the exploration and confusion?  Why not just teach the students how to multiply and divide fractions and be done with it?  Because that's not mathematics (see NIxtheTricks).  The symbols represent mathematical situations and mathematical thinking.  If students can only apply the rules to a problem you wrote on the page, and they can't think about it for themselves, or use the rules appropriately in a situation or word problem, then they haven't really learned anything useful. Division and multiplication describe what we do to stuff, and the symbols need to represent those operations, not replace them with math facts.  We will see just what those operations are in the next post.

1 Comment
Peter Glynn
2/16/2016 11:59:03 am

Hello Doug,

Thank you for the insightful post. I have equally felt the challenge of kids quickly leaping to the rules, particularly when taught by well-meaning parents. I try to address this by making the connection between the rules and the concepts.

I like the idea of using a real-world context for exploring 13 divided by 5. In fact, there are two ways of thinking about this problem as you noted. When looking at it as how many 5's in 13, using volume is useful. "How many 5 ounce cups can I pour into a 13 oz jug?". Students should see that after two full 5 oz cups, a fractional part of a the 5 oz part will provide the remaining liquid required. The pizza context is helpful for exploring how to equally divide 13 into 5 equal parts. I think it is good for students to go back to the simple problem of how to split one pizza equally for 5 kids, and then recognize they need to 13 of those 1/5's.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    April 2021
    February 2021
    November 2020
    July 2019
    April 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    October 2016
    August 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    November 2014

    Categories

    All
    3 Acts
    Big Teaching Ideas
    Fraction Operations
    Functions
    Geometry
    Math 7
    Modeling
    Patterns
    Practice
    Sequences

    RSS Feed


    These are a few of My Favorite Things...

    Finding Ways - Fawn Nguyen
    Divisible by 3 - Andrew Stadel
    Visual Patterns
    dy/dan - Dan Meyer
    Open Middle
    #slowmathchat
    Robert Kaplinsky

    _

All original content copyright Doug McKenzie, 2014-2021


Proudly powered by Weebly